Café
2323
A specialty coffee shop on Norfolk Row that changes its three or four roasts every two to three weeks.
City Centre
The modern centre took shape around the Peace Gardens, opened in 1997, and the Winter Garden, which followed in 2002 and links the Victorian Town Hall with the Millennium Galleries. Around them: coffee at 2323 and Caffè Tucci, cocktails at Public beneath the Town Hall, cider at the Old Shoe, and Maria and Grazie for dinner.
Food & Drink in City Centre
Café
Caffè Tucci
A Neapolitan caffè and deli on Surrey Street, serving Italian coffee, food and produce.
Bakery
Forge Bakehouse
A Sheffield bakery making sourdough and pastry by hand since 2012, with properly made coffee. It has branches on Abbeydale Road and Ecclesall Road, at the station, and further out.
Restaurant
Grazie
A Puglian restaurant on Leopold Street, where the pasta is rolled and shaped by hand every day.
Restaurant
Maria
A southern Italian-inspired trattoria on Wellington Street, from the team behind Bench, named after owner Ronnie Aronica's grandmother. Seats at the counter face the open kitchen.
Bar
Not Open; Don't Come
A speakeasy-style fine wine bar on the first floor above the Old Shoe, reached through a fire exit in the red wall on Orchard Street. You call the number on the door to get in, and it's open late Wednesday to Saturday.
Pub
Old Shoe
A cider and craft beer bar in a former shoe shop on Orchard Square, opened in 2023 by the Bear and Exemption Cider, which makes cider on the premises. It was CAMRA's Sheffield Cider Pub of the Year 2025.
Pub
Public
A table-service cocktail bar in the former gents' toilets beneath the Grade I-listed Town Hall, open since 2017.